It's no secret by now that Ho Chi Minh really admired the founding principles of the United States. He even quoted Thomas Jefferson from the American Declaration of Independence in his declaration of independence for Vietnam.
Many academics say, he was really into self-determination and appreciated America's history.
Until the early 1960s. Probably.
And he was right to trust the World War II-era United States to ensure a free Vietnam after WWII. Except he wasn't dealing with the same America after that war ended. Instead, the high-minded anti-colonial Roosevelt administration was gone, replaced by the anti-communist Truman administration.
As World War II came to a close, Uncle Ho was an agent of the U.S. Office of Strategic Services. As the OSS man in Vietnam, he was the chief organizer of anti-Japanese resistance. When the Japanese surrendered to the Allies, ending WWII, he moved to ensure the French didn't return. And history shows, the French weren't exactly the kindest of colonizers.
Maybe if they fought in Paris as hard as they fought in Algeria the French wouldn't have lost Vietnam in the first place.
It turns out Ho Chi Minh sent a number of telegrams to President Truman after the end of WWII. At the same time, he urged the Vietnamese people to rise up, capture arms and rice stocks, and keep the French from replacing the Japanese as their imperial masters. Truman never read any of the telegrams – there isn't even evidence that the President received Ho's messages.
One of the telegrams, written in 1945, asked Truman to make Vietnam an overseas protectorate of the United States, on par with Puerto Rico's relationship with America. He was willing to trade complete independence of his country for American democracy – better than British, French, or Japanese Imperialism... at least it was in Ho's mind.
Until the early 1960s. Probably.
Protectorates are officially "insular areas of the United States." They are administered by the federal government, but are not part of a state or federal district. Many of the U.S.-occupied islands in the Pacific would become American protectorates after World War II, so the idea isn't as outlandish as it seems today.
The Marshall Islands, Samoa, Guam, and the Marianas all have protectorate status.
It might have actually been a good plan for the long term. If Truman accepted Ho's idea, there have been many examples of U.S. protectorates that gained full independence after a while. The Philippines and Cuba are a couple of examples of this kind of self-determination. They weren't examples of clean history and not a clean break, but still a break.
On Oct. 16, 1945, just a few weeks after the Japanese surrender aboard the USS Missouri, Japanese and British planes bombed French positions in a coordinated attack to promote the French position there. Ho Chi Minh got his answer from the West. France broke its promise to Franklin Roosevelt, who demanded the French give up its colonies in Indochina.
Japanese sentries salute French officers in Saigon, 1945.
Not all of America was behind supporting the French. General Douglas MacArthur, for example, was livid.
"If there's anything that makes my blood boil," MacArthur said, "it is to see our allies in Indochina deploy Japanese troops to reconquer those little people we promised to liberate."