---
title: "World War II leaders Patton and Montgomery clashed over Italian prostitutes"
description: "Disease has traditionally been more devastating to armies than the enemy—and venereal disease is preventable."
date: "2026-11-14"
modified: "2026-11-14"
authors:
  - name: "Logan Nye"
    job_title: "Senior Contributor, Army Veteran"
    link: "https://www.wearethemighty.com/authors/logan-nye.md"
url: "https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/world-war-ii-leaders-patton-and-montgomery-clashed-over-italian-prostitutes/"
categories:
  - "History"
  - "War History"
  - "World War II"
tags:
  - "Battlefield Medicine"
  - "Military History"
  - "United Kingdom"
  - "World War II"
---

# World War II leaders Patton and Montgomery clashed over Italian prostitutes

![A collage shows Bernard Montgomery, George Patton, and a WW2 poster decrying prostitution for its role in sexually transmitted diseases](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Patton-Montgomery-Prostitution.jpg>)
*(WATM/Logan Nye)*

Military leaders had a tough challenge in World War II. They needed to build large armies of strong men who were willing to thrust hard, drive deep, and bust through. But then they had to convince all those same hard-charging men not to do those same things with their penile appendages (I'm not allowed to say "p\*nis").

**Also Read: [The Army’s desperate World War I fight for privates’ parts](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-history/wwi-fight-against-stds.md>)**

But Allied soldiers adept with rifles, carbines, and submachine guns have a tendency to shoot their shot regardless of the weapon caliber they're packing. Eventually, that leads to all sorts of malfunctions, like weapons that leak liquids that definitely are not Cleaner, Lubricant, and Protectant.

The officers, whether they partook in the unholy communion themselves or not, had to try and limit the damage. At multiple points in World War II, venereal disease caused more casualties than combat. If a commander wanted their whole unit upright and ready to rumble, they had to mitigate this kind of damage. Since different armies had different cultural norms and different regulations, VD disruption in the ranks sometimes led to disruption between the armies' leaders.

Like when U.S. Army Lt. Gen. George S. Patton and British Gen. Bernard Montgomery smashed clashed over Italian prostitutes and venereal disease.

![veneral disease cartoon animal prophylaxis sailor neck run US Navy 1940 United States Navy, circa 1940-1945 Box Oversize flat 1 and map case drawer 11 Title When you've stuck your neck out... Contributors U.S. Navy Date 1940 Extent 18" x 24" Physical Form Poster Type of Resource Still Image Subject Health education World War, 1939-1945. United States. Posters Military education Language eng Physical location University of Minnesota Libraries, Social Welfare History Archives. world war II prostitutes http://purl.umn.edu/62384 Access conditions Use of this image may be governed by U.S. and international copyright laws. Please contact the Social Welfare History Archives for permission to publish this image. http://special.lib.umn.edu/swha/](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ww2-venereal-disease-long-giraffe.jpg>)
*The giraffe is a metaphor. For a penile appendage. This would go hard as a tattoo for your most insecure but funny friend. (U.S. Navy [via CUNY](<https://vdarchive.newmedialab.cuny.edu>))*

### The Field of "Play" in 1943

In July 1943, the Allies launched themselves into the Italian peninsula like they were an army of Tarantinos who just learned Italy has a distinct boot shape.

![world war II prostitutes kill bill scene](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Uma-thurman-Kill-bill-killing-buck.png>)
*This *would* be an image of the famous "Kill Bill" scene where Tarantino showed Uma Thurman's feet for a disturbing amount of time, but she's self-conscious about that, so here's her killing her assailant while still paralyzed. (Lionsgate/Miramax)*

Operation Husky saw Allied forces invade the island of Sicily, the soccer ball to Italy's boot. In just a month, Allied forces took about half the island, including the city of Palermo. This was great news for the war effort. The [Italian king soon removed dictator Benito Mussolini from power](<https://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/allied-campaign-italy-1943-45-timeline-part-one>), and the new government started secret negotiations to withdraw from the war entirely.

Great news for lonely Allied service members, especially since Palermo was a place where you could tour a dry cathedral or a wet canal with equal ease for just a small fee (please note that Palermo has no *literal* canals). This was a mixed bag for the people of Palermo, though.

It's time for a quick pause to the poorly written jokes to talk about it.

Fascism is dumb, like really dumb. No one is a member of a master race. Invading another country to prove that "I'm built different, bro" typically leads to things like mass starvation—and Palermo suffered that mass starvation from mid-1942 until its "liberation" in 1943.

No matter which country you're from, seeing all your men whipped on the battlefield sucks. Suddenly having more access to more food is great! But the fastest way for an Italian woman, young or old, to get an extra meal was to get it from a soldier exchanging their K-ration. For the young boys, their mother or sister made this exchange and shared it with them. Unfortunately, that meant a lot of women faced the stark options of prostitution or starvation.

And sure, Italy was one of the countries that started World War II and forced Europe into its darkest hour, but still, humans shouldn't have to face that choice, not even the fascists. Meanwhile, [Italian organized crime often skimmed the earnings](<https://rucore.libraries.rutgers.edu/rutgers-lib/50560/PDF/1/play/>) of women engaged in the trade, whether it was in an area with legalized prostitution or not.

That meant Palermo hosted lots of professional prostitutes used to taking men on tours of a wet qanat (The jokes are back, baby!) as well as new freelancers whose facilities weren't exactly an OSHA-approved break room.

VD was an immediate and urgent problem.

![A painting of canals is compared to a photo of a qanat.](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/canal-vs-qanat-cc-by-sa-3.0.jpg>)
*The one on the left is a canal, the one on the right is a qanat, and both are metaphors.*

### Dueling American and British Approaches

Unfortunately, the American and British approached the problem quite differently. Montgomery almost got sacked in 1939 for a leaflet that acknowledged 1) Even Brits like to bone, 2) They can catch and transmit venereal disease, and 3) There are practical steps to limit the spread and the damage.

This was, of course, a major crime against British sensibilities. High command almost fired Montgomery during wartime for it, and he learned not to touch that particular stove again.

![World War II venereal disease posters](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/VD-Posters-World-War-II.jpg>)
*Surely a few posters reminding troops that VD exists will stop them from having sex. Especially since they all have such long life expectancies. (U.S. government illustrations [via CUNY](<https://vdarchive.newmedialab.cuny.edu>))*

Meanwhile, Patton had no such millstone around his neck. [Palermo had legal prostitution that dated back to the 1800s](<https://www.academia.edu/50642195/Prostitution_in_Genoa_Naples_Palermo_and_Rome>), so Patton simply fell in on that model.

Author John Costello [wrote in 1985](<https://www.psywarrior.com/PSYOPVD.html>) about prostitution in the war and points out that Germany in World War I and II had great success in fighting VD by collecting fees and distributing medicine and prophylactics, usually condoms. Germany also kept records of which men were with which women so they could trace outbreaks. Patton adopted a similar model, sending U.S. Army teams into the largest brothels to monitor the spread of disease.

The British, meanwhile, relied on making sections of occupied cities off-limits and attempting to punish troops found there. That seems dubious even when prostitution was limited to professionals working out of set locations. In a city where almost every woman was a horizontal breadwinner, there likely wasn't a closet that wouldn't become a brothel within minutes for a few bucks or a quid.

Montgomery often catches flack for this in modern writing, including from Costello in 1985. But remember, again, he almost lost his job just four years prior for doing less than Patton had.

And the situation really came to a head in Naples just months later.

### "Wine and Girls Were as Plentiful as Food Was Scarce."

In his book "Love, Sex and War," Costello does a great job of [summarizing the 1943 situation in Naples](<https://www.heretical.com/costello/14govert.html>):

Naples became the main staging port for the gruelling Italian campaign as well as the principal rest and recreation centre for thousands of Allied troops. Wine and girls were as plentiful as food was scarce for its inhabitants, who were packed into what one British officer called ‘human rookeries.’ K-rations became the passport to the passion GIs discovered Latin women could bring to the most transient of casual sexual encounters. ‘Even when they aren’t in love the Italians ape the mannerisms of the lover. Thus they can be joyous at eighty.

Unfortunately for the American, British, and all other Allied leaders, the legal bordellos were limited in impact. A woman working in a military-regulated facility made a fraction of the money that a woman on the street could. If you're gonna take a soldier's bayonet, you might as well get $10 for it, but Patton's teams wanted you to get speared for $0.50.

The Brits even blamed the Germans for their troubles. Costello quoted a British circular from Christmas 1943:

From reports that have been received it is apparent that prostitution in occupied Italy, and Naples in particular, has reached a pitch greater than has ever been witnessed in Italy before. So much is this so that it has led to a suggestion that the encouragement of prostitution is part of a formulated plan arranged by the pro-Axis elements, primarily to spread venereal disease among Allied troops.

Apparently, Brits getting horny is a dead giveaway that the Germans are involved.

Meanwhile, despite the war moving increasingly into Europe and Allied troops finding themselves surrounded by large populations of women who looked like them, venereal disease rates among U.S. service members actually [hit their all-time low for the war in 1943](<https://achh.army.mil/history/book-wwii-communicablediseasesv5-appendixd>). So getting as much of the activity as possible into a facility and playing test-and-trace seems to have worked.

Of course, the war eventually ended 18 months later and troops no longer passed venereal disease between themselves via prostitutes. [Everyone lived happily ever after](<https://time.com/archive/6792739/medicine-vd-up/>).

**Don’t Miss the Best of We Are The Mighty**

**• [World War II alliances fueled the resurgence of the post-war American mafia](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/how-wartime-alliances-empowered-the-post-war-mafia.md>)**
**• [A former violinist singlehandedly cleared a mountain fortress during World War II](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/thomas-wigle-concert-violinist-monte-frassino-world-war-ii.md>)**
**• [The new Jimmy Stewart biopic depicts his World War II service](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/entertainment/new-jimmy-stewart-biopic-world-war-ii.md>)**

## Author
Logan was an Army journalist and paratrooper in the 82nd. Now, he's a freelance writer covering military history, culture, and technology. He has two upcoming podcasts and a Twitch channel focused on basic military literacy.

### Author social links  
[Twitter](<https://twitter.com/JustLoganNye>)  
[Facebook](<https://www.facebook.com/ProfHarlequin-111921498198749>)

## More

- [How Mafia boss Lucky Luciano joined World War II from his prison cell](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/mafia-boss-lucky-luciano-joined-world-war-ii-with-the-allies-from-his-prison-cell.md>)
- [How military spouses were targeted by propaganda during World War II](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-milspouse/how-military-spouses-were-targeted-by-propaganda-during-world-war-ii.md>)
- [Italian women quietly enabled a new front for the Allies in World War II](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/italian-women-world-war-ii.md>)
- [World War II alliances fueled the resurgence of the post-war American mafia](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/how-wartime-alliances-empowered-the-post-war-mafia.md>)
- [The 8 reincarnations of General George S. Patton](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-history/8-reincarnations-of-general-patton.md>)
- [The reason Gen. George Patton is buried in Luxembourg](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-history/general-patton-buried-in-luxembourg.md>)
- [Meet the dog who went from a family pet to a World War II hero](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/history/meet-the-dog-who-went-from-a-family-pet-to-a-world-war-ii-hero.md>)
- [This is how General Patton built up his tank division into the most formidable armored force of World War II](<https://www.wearethemighty.com/articles/this-is-how-general-patton-built-up-his-tank-division-into-the-most-formidable-armored-force-of-world-war-ii.md>)
