Why some Marines in combat zones don't get Combat Action Ribbons
The Marines in Afghanistan are definitely in combat, even if they are not being awarded the Combat Action Ribbon, the former commander of Task Force Southwest said on Feb. 1.
"It's absolutely a combat mission," Brig. Gen. Roger Turner Jr. told reporters at a roundtable. "The only difference is we're not maneuvering directly on the enemy. From the command element perspective: It's full spectrum combat. We shoot at the enemy, they shoot at us."
Turner led the task force of roughly 300 Marines from April 2017 until January 2018. During that time, Marines helped Afghan troops and interior ministry forces go on the offensive in Helmand province, the home of many senior Taliban leaders and a significant source of the opium that feeds the Taliban's coffers, he said.
Despite being deployed to Afghanistan for nine months, none of the Marines in the task force were awarded the Combat Action Ribbon, Marine Corps Times has reported. The CAR is a coveted decoration, especially by younger Marines, because it certifies combat experience.
Combat Action Ribbon awarded by the United States Department of the Navy. (Image Wikipedia)
But on Feb. 1, Turner cautioned against using the CAR as a litmus test to determine if the Marines in Afghanistan are on a combat mission.
"It's too simplistic to say that nobody earned the Combat Action Ribbon; therefore, they weren't in combat," Turner said. "They're very much in combat. We just weren't achieving the criteria of the Combat Action Ribbon."
The CAR recognizes Marines who have taken part in direct action against the enemy, according to the decoration's requirements. Marines who come under direct fire or are exposed to explosions can be eligible for the award. The CAR is typically not given to Marines who come under indirect fire unless they engage in offensive counter-fire operations.
With help from the Marines, Afghan security forces went on the offensive for 250 days of the 280-day deployment, Turner said. The Marines advised the Afghans at various levels of command and helped coordinate artillery and air support.
Even though the Marines did not fight alongside Afghan units, they were attacked by Taliban rockets and mortars about 20 times during the deployment, Turner said. None of the Marines were wounded.
On Jan. 15, Turner transferred command to Brig. Gen. Benjamin Watson, who commands a larger task force that will be able to have U.S. military advisers permanently assigned to Afghan battalions, Turner said.
Watson has told Task & Purpose that he has the authority to allow Marines to accompany Afghan troops and police into battle, if needed.
A U.S. Marine with Task Force Southwest fires the M-27 Infantry Automatic Rifle as part of the combat marksmanship program at Camp Shorabak, Afghanistan, Jan. 26, 2018. Task Force Southwest is continually working on combat marksmanship to ensure proper sustainment of basic Marine combat skills, so they can better train, advise and assist the Afghan National Defense and Security Forces.
(U.S. Marine Corps photo by Sgt. Conner Robbins)
"Whether or not we exercise that authority is going to depend on how we assess the situation at the time, and obviously I'm not going to get into specifics on that," Watson said in a Jan. 15 interview.
After nearly 16 years of war in Afghanistan, it is not clear how much of territory the Taliban controls outright or is contesting. Marine Lt. Gen. Kenneth F. McKenzie Jr., director of the Joint Staff, said the U.S. estimates that the Afghan government controls about 60%of the country, but a recent BBC report claims the Taliban is active in 70% of Afghanistan.
McKenzie said he does not believe the BBC story is accurate, adding that he "couldn't completely follow their logic as stated in the article."
"We certainly don't think that the Taliban has a presence to some degree in 70% of the countryside – and we would disagree with that," McKenzie told reporters Feb. 1 during a Pentagon news briefing.