When the police arrived at a retirement community in Utah to conduct a welfare check last month, they were disturbed to find not only the body of the elderly woman who lived there, but a man's corpse tucked inside a deep freezer in her utility room.
That man was eventually identified as Paul Mathers, who was 58 years old when he was last seen in 2009. He was the husband of the 75-year-old woman also found in the home, Jeanne Souron-Mathers.
"I've been here 13 years — this is one of the strangest cases," Tooele City Police Department Sgt. Jeremy Hansen told news outlets, adding, "We've never had anything like this."
He said police officers had opened Souron-Mathers' fridge and freezer hoping to find food that would indicate "some type of a timeline" for when she died. But when a detective opened a deep freezer in the utility room, he "immediately finds an unidentified deceased adult male in the freezer," Hansen said.
The police made the discovery on November 22 and initially called the incident "very suspicious."
But after several weeks of investigating, the police announced on Monday that they'd found several equally bizarre clues that might help explain the incident.
Hansen said investigators searching through Souron-Mathers' home found a notarized letter from December 2008 that appeared to be from Mathers, declaring that he was not killed by his wife.
"We believe he had a terminal illness," Hansen told KSTU, adding that Mathers likely died sometime between February 4, 2009 — the date of his last appointment at a Veterans Affairs hospital — and March 8, 2009.
Hansen also told The Salt Lake Tribune that experts had not yet verified whether the signature on the letter truly belonged to Mathers. He added that the woman who notarized the letter in 2008 told the police she never read the document before stamping and signing it.
Investigators also discovered that Souron-Mathers had collected roughly $177,000 in Veterans Affairs benefits after her husband's death and are still looking into whether she continued to receive Mathers' Social Security benefits, Hansen said.
Hansen told The Tribune that they were still awaiting an autopsy report to confirm the cause of Mathers' death but that detectives were "wrapping up" their investigation.
This article originally appeared on Insider. Follow @thisisinsider on Twitter.
- The sheriff's deputy seen slamming an 11-year-old onto the ground in a viral video has been charged with assault
- Thousands of Las Vegas shooting victims will have to split an $800 million settlement. Now, 2 retired judges have to decide which victims deserve the most.
- Parents of an 8-year-old boy who died by suicide are suing the Cincinnati school where he was bullied. Officials are arguing they're not responsible for eliminating student violence.
- An Oregon town couldn't afford to hire cops for the night shift, so it proposed installing security cameras manned by volunteers who can identify 'hardcore criminals' just by looking at them
- A self-taught baker made an incredible Baby Yoda pie for the holidays