This past summer, the British and Russians exchanged trash talk over carriers. That all started when the then-Defense Secretary, Michael Fallon, called the Admiral Kuznetsov "dilapidated." The Russians responded by calling the first of the Royal Navy's new carriers, HMS Queen Elizabeth, "a large, convenient target" and warned the Brits to keep their distance.
Now, both carriers have had their problems. If you're a loyal WATM reader, you have followed the Kuznetsov Follies. We are talking a first deployment that featured two splash landings, needing to operate planes from land bases, not to mention the fact that the new fighter is a possible dud and the carrier is a floating hell for the crew.
A Su-33 Flanker prepares to take off from the Admiral Kuznetsov. (Youtube screenshot)
HMS Queen Elizabeth has a problem of her own, though. No planes. In fact, she may have to operate F-35Bs from the United States Marine Corps, which will require some adjustments. Any fight here would be tough to call, but give the Brits the edge. Once the F-35s clear out the Kuznetsov's air wing (largely because they are far more advanced than MiG-29s and Su-33s), the Kuznetsov will only have 12 SS-N-19 Shipwreck missiles to use. No problem for the Queen Elizabeth's escorts.
But how well would the Kuznetsov fare against an American carrier? If anything, it's even more of a slaughter. According to the 16th Edition of Combat Fleets of the World, the Kuznetsov can carry 18 Su-33 Flankers or MiG-29K Fulcrums, four Su-25 Frogfoot trainers, 15 Ka-27 Helix ASW helicopters, and two Ka-31 Helix airborne early warning choppers.
Russian Navy Ka-31 with its radar extended. (Wikimedia Commons)
By comparison, it should be noted that a typical American carrier air wing has four strike-fighter squadrons of F/A-18E/F Super Hornets or F/A-18C Hornets, each with a dozen multi-role fighters. So, the Russians are fighting at the wrong end of eight-to-three odds. The American carrier's air wing, by the way, does offer electronic-warfare assets as well.
Once the Kuznetsov's fighters are gone, the American carrier can then either launch an alpha strike to sink the Kuznetsov, or support an attack by B-1B Lancers carrying LRASMs. Either way, the Kuznetsov is going down. Heck, even an old Midway-class carrier could take the Kuznetsov.
Sailors position an F/A-18F Super Hornet assigned to the "Checkmates" of Strike Fighter Squadron (VFA) 211 prior to its launch from the aircraft carrier USS Harry S. Truman (CVN 75). Harry S. Truman is underway conducting flight deck certifications in preparation for future operations. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Anthony Flynn/Released)
For another take on how the Kuznetsov would fare, check out the video below. Then let us know who you think would win this fight in the comments.