What veterans can learn from the classic movie ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’

And what they can learn from Jimmy Stewart's real life.
It's a wonderful life
"It's a Wonderful Life" hit theaters in 1946.

“It’s a Wonderful Life” is a Christmas tradition in my home – and has been in many American homes over the decades. The film hearkens back to a bygone era where characters from the Greatest Generation grow up before our eyes. We feel their joy, sorrow, and redemption on a personal level. It’s funny, sad, and triumphant all at once.

Having served three combat tours, this film now holds an important place in my heart. What it teaches today’s veterans makes it more than just a holiday film.

How many realize that a real-life war hero plays the discouraged character of George Bailey? In 1941, Jimmy Stewart received an Academy Award for Best Actor, but weeks later, he enlisted in the Army Air Corps. With his significant civilian flying experience and degree, he was soon commissioned as a pilot, performing duties that included publicity and flight instruction.

Stewart was not satisfied with this limited role, and eventually fought his way into an assignment flying B-24 Liberator bombers, rising to Chief of Staff for the 2nd Combat Wing, 8th Air Force. On one of his 20 bombing missions over Nazi-occupied Europe, his unit lost 13 planes and 130 men to enemy fighters and anti-aircraft guns.

He was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross. But the horrors he witnessed had made him “flak happy,” crushing him mentally. Reluctantly, Stewart was sent home to recover.

It's a wonderful life
Theatrical poster for “It’s a Wonderful Life.” Theatrical poster for the release of the 1946 film It’s a Wonderful Life, starring James Stewart and Donna Reed.

When he returned from the war, he was haunted by the experiences he had in combat. Fearing that his Hollywood career might be over, he returned to California looking for work. Fresh young actors were taking roles that previously would have been Stewart’s for the picking. The stress of war made the 37-year-old look more like he was 50, dashing his hopes of being a leading man again. He knew he had to do something. At first, he wanted to do a comedy, as he felt there was enough sorrow in the world at the time.

Eventually, director Frank Capra convinced him to play the lead role of George Bailey.  

Filming the classic movie was arduous, with a visibly changed Stewart struggling tremendously with post-traumatic stress. It was apparent to the cast and crew that Stewart was drawing heavily from the anguish and fear he felt flying over Nazi Germany. That’s what makes his performance so meaningful. A near-suicidal George Bailey was really Jimmy Stewart trying desperately to come to grips with the nightmare of World War II. 

Watch the film again and see the raw emotion on full display. As Stewart prays desperately at Martini’s bar for help from God, you see a man absolutely broken. Those on the set were understandably shocked at what was happening. Stewart was unleashing a torrent of emotion, baring his very soul for all to see. It’s as pure a performance as you’ll find in cinema. This was the role that likely saved the actor’s career and perhaps set him on the path to true recovery.

In the wake of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” Stewart’s career was back on track. He reclaimed his place as America’s leading man. Serving his country was in his blood, though. He refused to allow his wartime experience to define him. He pushed through his pain. In something never seen in today’s entertainment industry, Stewart even continued serving in the Air Force Reserve. He flew his last bombing mission in Vietnam and retired as a brigadier general in 1968.

He redefined himself as an actor and never forgot the importance of selfless service. It was his willingness to embrace the tragedies in his life that transformed him, and it’s an example for today’s veterans to follow.

Screenshot of Jimmy Stewart, Donna Reed, and Karolyn Grimes in the 1946 film “It’s a Wonderful Life.” Screenshot of Jimmy Stewart, Donna Reed, and Karolyn Grimes in the American film It’s a Wonderful Life (1946).

I once saw a young patient dying in front of me as the medics removed him from my MEDEVAC helicopter. It seemed like he was staring through me. After that moment, I couldn’t speak to anyone for some time. It was as if I were outside my body, watching myself experience something over which I had no control. I thought I was weak. Eventually, I talked it out with my buddy. Writing my book also helped me. Since then, I have realized that I wasn’t weak. I didn’t have a “disorder.” I faced something abnormal, and I wasn’t alone. 

There’s an awful lot of George Baileys in this country. They answered the call. They sacrificed their own dreams for others’ dreams. They defended the disheartened and led from the front. They and their families have given up so much, but now they question if their sacrifices were all for nothing. Some are on that snowy bridge next to George Bailey right now, staring into that icy river, that permanent solution to a temporary problem.

If you’re struggling, stay the course. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with you. It’s the situation you were in that was wrong. What’s wrong isn’t how you dealt with life and death situations or how you handled the loss of friends. What you did and what you saw was not normal. You aren’t the problem. You are a hero for having survived the trauma. 

Now is the time for you to confront it and then use the experience for good. The clouds will part, I promise you. You are not broken. Reach out to the friends who were there with you and talk. You might think it’s just to help you, but I believe it might also help them; they may have been too scared to reach out on their own. 

So… be there this Christmas for an old friend. Call one old buddy this week and talk. 

“Remember, George: no man is a failure who has friends.”

Erik Sabiston Avatar

Erik Sabiston

Contributor

Erik Sabiston is the bestselling author of Dustoff 7-3, host of the Make the Donuts podcast, owner of Sabiston Consulting and the founder of RTAG – The Veteran to Aviation. He was an Army rescue pilot and now flies for a legacy airline.
Find his podcast here:
Get in touch with Erik here:

Learn more about WeAreTheMighty.com Editorial Standards