If not for a twist of fate, the 1948 VC-121A Lockheed Constellation that once transported the nation's 34thpresident might have become a crop duster or turned into scrap metal.
The Columbine II was the first plane to fly with the call sign "Air Force One" when it carried President Dwight D. Eisenhower for the first two years of his administration. However, the aircraft would have been lost to history without the intervention of three men – one who bought the plane almost 50 years ago, the friend who helped save it from the scrap heap, and the man whose aviation company purchased it two decades later with plans to restore it to its 1950s glory.
"I didn't want to see somebody drinking a beer and wonder if the metal from that can came from that plane," said Karl D. Stoltzfus, whose Dynamic Aviation Company purchased the "Connie," as Lockheed Constellations are commonly called, in 2015.
In March, Stoltzfus had the aircraft flown for the first time in 13 years, except for a brief test flight a few days earlier, to Dynamic Aviation in Bridgewater, Virginia. Lockie Christler, son of the late Mel Christler, who bought the plane from the Air Force in 1970, flew the Columbine II from Marana Regional Airport, Arizona, where it had sat since 2003, to Virginia. The almost 60-year-old plane made a stop at the Mid-America Flight Museum in Mount Pleasant, Texas, before Christler made the final four-hour flight to Bridgewater, with Stoltzfus piloting the chase plane, a Beechcraft King Air.
Christler gives most of the credit for the Columbine II's restoration to his father, who died in 2005, Stoltzfus and Harry Oliver, who emphasized the importance of saving the plane and was the majority owner when it was sold.
"If it weren't for men like my father, Harry and Karl, along with others, a lot of these airplanes wouldn't be around," Christler said. "Once we realized this was Eisenhower's airplane, we couldn't let it be scrapped."
The plane was built as a C-121A at Burbank, California, and converted to a VC-121A-LO to carry VIPs in 1953. The Columbine II, named after the Colorado state flower by first lady Mamie Eisenhower, became the official presidential aircraft later that year. Over New Charlotte, North Carolina the following year, an Eastern Airlines flight had the same call numbers as the Columbine II, and confusion ensued when both planes shared the same airspace. Because of the incident, the "Air Force One" call sign became used for any plane the president was on board.
The plane, while hardly resembling the Air Force One flown by presidents from John F. Kennedy to Barack Obama, included marble floors and a mahogany desk where Eisenhower wrote the "Atoms for Peace" speech he gave to the U.N. General Assembly in 1953. The Columbine II also took him to Korea, both as a president-elect and during his administration.
In 1954, the aircraft was replaced by the Columbine III, which Eisenhower used for the remainder of his presidency. The Columbine II continued in service as a VIP transport for Eisenhower's vice president, Richard M. Nixon, and others, such as Queen Elizabeth II, before it was finally retired to Davis-Monthan Air Force Base, Arizona, in 1968. The Air Force stripped the aircraft and fitted it with mismatched landing gear, an error that, in an odd twist of fate, led to the aircraft being spared from destruction long enough for its historical value to be discovered by its new owners.
Up for auction
The Columbine II was sold to Christler as part of a package lot with four other Connies for $35,000 in a surplus auction at the Davis-Monthan AFB aircraft "boneyard." He didn't know one of the five planes had a presidential past and planned to make it part of his crop-dusting operation. Christler rebuilt the other four VC-121s for spraying operations, but didn't convert the Columbine II because its starboard main gear had been replaced with the wrong part from a Lockheed 1049 Super Constellation. The incorrect landing gear, again, saved the Columbine II from being converted to a crop-duster. Instead, it was used for supplying the other four Connies with parts.
Mel Christler was considering cutting the aircraft up as scrap when Robert Mikesh of the Smithsonian Institution contacted him in 1980 and informed him that his Connie with the serial number 48-610 was a former presidential aircraft.
"The first time we saw it, we obviously didn't realize whose plane it was," Lockie Christler said, "but when you find out it was Eisenhower's, now you're stuck with it. You have a presidential plane you can't melt up because people wouldn't think very highly of you. So, for all of these years, it's kind of been a liability, and it finally turned into an asset."
Christler tried to find a buyer who could restore the Columbine II, but couldn't find one. He was struggling to decide what to do with the plane when Oliver visited him at his Greybull, Wyoming, home in August 1989, and asked about his plans for the Columbine II. Oliver said Christler planned to send the plane to the smelter if he didn't have a buyer by November.
"I just said, 'Now we can't do that,'" Oliver said. "'It's a little bit of history, and it should be saved."
At Christler's request, Oliver drove to Tucson, Arizona, with a friend to look at the plane and saw the damage, but thought it wasn't anything that couldn't be repaired. The two men completed a $150,000 functional restoration of the Columbine II in 1990 and had it flown to Abilene, Kansas for Eisenhower's centennial celebration. Afterward, they moved the Connie to Roswell and Santa Fe, New Mexico, before it was flown to Marana, where it remained under a lease agreement until it was sold to Stoltzfus in 2015.
Stoltzfus, a self-proclaimed history buff, learned about the Columbine II from an article in an aviation magazine and wanted to see the plane restored to its 1950s condition so he asked one person what he should do – his then-8-year-old grandson. "I think we should buy it," the boy told him.
Then Stoltzfus asked his twin brother Ken to check out the plane in Arizona. After hearing that there wasn't any damage that couldn't be overcome, he sent Dynamic Aviation mechanics to begin repairs. When he first saw the plane, it was in rough condition.
"Every hose, I mean every piece of rubber was bad," Stoltzfus said. "There were a lot of things about the airplane that gave you reason to say this was going to be a lot of work. They hadn't really run the engines, but you knew there was going to be a lot of trouble with them, and there was. But the good part was it didn't have any corrosion. Otherwise, we wouldn't have bought the airplane."
Although he can't divulge the actual price he paid, Stoltzfus said it was less than the $1.5 million listing price. Dynamic Aviation will begin a full restoration project on the Columbine II in three to six months, which Stoltzfus expects to be completed in two to three years. He has obtained drawings and documentation that he hopes will help him restore the plane to its original color codes and original manufacturer materials.
"I think the airplane can be used to educate people on the 1950s, not just about Air Force One and not just about Eisenhower," he said. "These were generally considered to be good years in America. They weren't perfect, but they were generally good. We got out of the Korean War, so it was a peaceful time, and it was a good time economically and was when we started to build the interstate. So it was just a good time in American history."
When it's fully restored, Stoltzfus hopes to take the historic aircraft to air shows and display it for the public at the company's airport in Bridgewater. In the meantime, he's looking for anyone who might have aircraft parts or stories to share from the Connie's era.
Oliver is grateful that somebody was interested enough in saving the plane.
"When I started this project, I was 52 years old, and I'm 77 now," he said. "I don't have the energy to do it anymore, and I'm just glad that somebody does. It is a piece of history, and now it's going to be where people can see it, smell it and touch it."
Once the silver Connie with the purple flower on its nose is restored to its Air Force One glory, it will have three men to credit for saving this piece of American history for future generations.
Even though one of the three didn't live to see the Columbine II's restoration, his son thinks it would have made him proud.
"Oh, he's got a big smile on his face right now," Christler said. "I know he's proud that it has a great home where it's supposed to be. It's within a hundred miles of Washington, D.C, where it had some important flying to do."